This would be optimal scoring for mvp to me in each game mode.
TDM, Execution, and Warzone - Needs to be based on +/- KD. (8 kills 5 deaths would be a +/- of 3)
Highest earns mvp…tie breakers go to more kills… if those are the same then more points.
KOTH - generally speaking this is the most correctly done with the current score system.
But, kills should be worth more while in or near the ring to promote attacking/defending the point.
Guardian - by far the worst with the current score system. Needs to have better points tied to assisting a leader to a kill, killing enemies near your leader, assisting killing enemy leader, and killing enemy leader.
The only bonus they give is for surviving as leader and who is to say it is the leader who “earned” those points that round…definitely needs tuning to determine a better mvp than killing a bunch of nobodies nowhere near either leader.
Escalation - Generally speaking this is the same as KOTH, except THE ORIGINAL HOME BASE RING CAP SHOULD NOT BE WORTH POINTS.
God I hate seeing some guy near the top because he can run to the easiest cap in the game while 2 people fight for the middle ring to get maybe 2 kills more worth of points or get killed and earn nothing and then lose position on the map.
Also the original Middle ground ring cap needs to be worth at least 1.5X points…controlling the middle is key and giving points to entice your team to help get it at the start would make those important battles bigger and not always lopsided to stacked teams.
That’s my two cents…I never trust score boards in objective based modes because I know who is doing good and who isn’t based on how the players look, who is moving with leaders, pushing the attack, and how often I get into battles with the same people by objectives.
Score isn’t everything…too many times I’m glad I bust out a lancer or snub on people to support them and end up with a down. I might get 20+ points and them 100+ points but if you don’t show up and get that extra damage in to force a down that enemy might just kill the other guy and nobody gets points for your team.