Ascendance states for Kait to prefer lin range engagements with her picking an EMBAR as the next best weapon to a Longshot. Heck, she even starts with a damn Longshot in both Gears 4 and 5 in Act 1. But she just gets a close combat role slapped on with a cloaking ability. The justification? “She was out in the wilds in Campaign.”… even though they literally go as far as then hinting at JD and Del surviving in the Deadlands as part of their COG training, so it literally holds no weight. Her role isn’t even “Scout” proper when you’re not doing recon activities. The closest is going on a stabbing spree amidst the enemies when you have Cloak active.
And I would generally expect a soldier in a military to be capable of handling and adapting to a variety of situations, but it doesn’t mean combat preferences don’t exist.
I don’t think this whole approach is working very well anyway. I mean, we’re playing a shooter here, but TC isn’t even designing certain characters with offensive purposes in mind at all(Lizzie is one of the characters who gets no damage bonuses at all, currently) and their atrocious enemy balance just makes the “Tank” aspect of that role nearly fully redundant when you still get put in the ground extremely quickly no matter your damage reductions. Not even Lizzie’s Stim is 100% foolproof. And all it takes to bring the Silverback down is some of the ridiculous Drone Elites or two Mulchers, depending on difficulty and active modifiers.
There isn’t even real individuality when almost everything you see when players are not JD or Kait is Tri-Shot or more rarely Salvo spamming. Even on the mid difficulty levels. And while this is a different issue entirely that is also perhaps personal, JDs almost always seem to take it as their devoted task to try killing nearly every single enemy they can reach on the map, even when it makes the other offensive roles basically redundant. Why would I play Kait if it wasn’t to KILL enemies?
I really would wish I could say I expect TCs “balance pass” for Horde to make it that not everyone is basically just a support tool for JD/Kait/Fahz/Keegan/very maybe Marcus, but I really don’t…