I’d argue that Valera isn’t too difficult to include as a) like you note she’s voiced by Laura Bailey, who also voiced Alexa Brand who I believe will eventually also be included in Gears 5. It makes little sense to include someone with no in game story and to exclude someone who has featured in an in game story - from the voice actor of the protagonist of the series. A character from a really popular DLC: RAAM’s Shadow, b) she’s also featured in the campaign, with a collectible from her brother and honouring her death along with other collectibles of dead Gears at the end of the campaign. So even for those who didn’t play RAAM’s Shadow or the past Gears games, people can still find a link to her and c) we’re starting to run out of popular characters to include. One of the last would be Hofman, of which I’m pretty sure he’ll be included in the next OP. If TC wants to keep on including characters, they would need to keep some extra in reserve for the series’ runtime until significant resources are being put in Gears 6.
I actually like her for her personality: she was portrayed as a caring person willing to fight to the end to rescue others, she even attacked RAAM to safe Jace. The concept of her outfit was also interesting, I believe it was introduced as the recon/scout outfit for COG soldiers. It was the first time we’ve seen that sort of armour. And yes, as an extra bonus she looks pretty good as well.
Barrick is an interesting case, as you point out. There should be a creative way to include him in the game, regardless if TC still holds the anti-smoking policy. I believe Rod was the main driver behind that, and he’s been gone for some time now.


so I won’t pretend that I don’t hold out hope for this game.