I just think its easy to see disk error messages and assume it must relate to something physical - its the sort of thing tech support does when you raise a ticket - they scan ,find a message, and blame that telling you to update your drivers rather than fix their stuff.
Lots of people get a large number of event 51 with this game and no other. This is not the characteristic of a hardware problem but of some issue with the way the game is accessing the xvd at startup.
)