Where exactly are these figures coming from? Because I have not seen any numbers that actually include all sales of both physical and digital copies of the game. At the time this game released digital, was and still is a highly used method to purchase games which typically is not recorded in any sort of sales numbers.
You know why Gears 1 and 2 had such “Grit”? Gears of War was the first game to use the Unreal Engine 3, and the color pallette was not very large… Gears of War 2, you started seeing more color and more depth because the engine had time to grow. Then Gears of War 3 you really started to see the difference in just the landscapes they used to display everything…
Like someone said about, it’s evolution… Technology evolves, and to survive the company evolves with it. They have to… Which brings me to the next poing…
Rapper/Halo/Terminator… It’s marketing, again what companies do to make more money… There are die hard Halo fans out there that will see Halo skins in Gears and jump in, just because of that. It will be the same with any other skin you see that is outside the Gears universe… It’s just smart marketing… You put things in the end game to draw people in… Me personally, I don’t care if they put Thanos in the MP skin rotation… As long as the gameplay mechanics are solid, and I have a FUN time playing it…
The story is deeper than just the game… If you don’t like it, cool… It you do, and you haven’t I recommend reading all of the books… It is a great story… The books do a wonderful job of filling in all of the gaps in the games… And give a lot of back story…
In the end, it is always a personal preference on weather you like a game or not… For me, I can only speak to over the last 13 years how much fun and how many memories I have from playing this series with my friends… And the amount of people I have met and played with because of this game… So many relationships have been formed…
So identity crisis? No… No there is no identity crisis… It’s the evolution of the game… It’s keeping many of the core game mechanics while making changes to keep up with the times… I have no issue giving feedback that will include specific items of what I’m not happy with. This is Gears in the center…
If you don’t like something because of character skins, and it doesn’t have “Grid” IE they take advantage of updates software and hardware cool… That is totally your choice… To me, it seems like a shallow opinion but that’s just me…
Have you played Gears since 2006, is that why you are a “true” fan?