Feedback regarding running for time in Escape (including list of enemies and how much worth they are with the different "killtypes")

Gears 5
#1

First things first, here’s the Excel with the full list of enemies and how much worth they are (on the right side you can set hive difficulty and levels of your score cards):

https://1drv.ms/x/s!Ag9UWHQHbsIjl0rOMER8JhgrEpi2?e=GOoSa9

Surprisingly, it’s the Matriarch that’s worth the most, not the Swarmak.

General
Some of you probably know me already. I generally like the challenge of achieving the best possible time in any Escape hive together with my team. It puts the hives to a completely new challenge. I really like the idea of actually having to kill all the enemies to save on time. However there’s some flaws with it which I believe should be addressed and corrected, which can make the time runs sometimes quite RNG heavy if not corrected. Obviously we time runners (that’s what I’m gonna call us now) are a minority of the community, yet I’d still love to see a couple fixes to make the runs more equal, with equal chances for everyone (if they grinded enough cards).

Flaw 1: Uneven RNG enemy distribution in each chapter
Unfortunately each chapter has at least two different RNGs in every hive. Meaning whatever RNG you can get in the first act, the second act will also have a different RNG everytime you reach it. Usually Scions the ones, that are making the difference. Take The Barracks act 2 for example. You can either have a bunch of Mulcher Scions paired with Dropshot Scions or a bunch of Salvo Scions paired with Ice Scions (and a few Buzzkill Scions). When looking at the list, Ice and Salvo Scions are already worth 5 seconds more than Mulcher and Dropshot Scions. Pair that with all the modifiers and an active headshot, and you’ll have ~30 seconds difference between each one of them.
This flaw is probably the biggest pain because it can lead to countless restarts simply because you have the RNG which eventually results in a worse time.

Flaw 2: Meatshields
This is probably the second biggest flaw. For whatever reason, the meatshields count the enemy twice. Once you initiate the meatshield and once you somehow get rid of it. This can lead to very strange things like ALHM which will be explained in flaw 3 just below. In my opinion, an execution is the hardest to pull-off, therefore it should award you the most time for doing so. The meatshield does count as an execution but is bugged and counts the enemy twice. Fixing this will change the meta of running for time for quite a bunch and even out the times from the different times a lot better.

Flaw 3: ALHM (Active Longshot Headshot Meatshield)
The most broken mechanic that we discovered when we worked on Lethal Engagements. It is currently already known by a bunch of people here. Meatshielding counts twice as described above, but if you manage to pull off an active headshot on the meatshield, it actually applies the hidden x4 headshot multiple from the active bullet. So basically you killed the same enemy in two different ways. Why exactly only a Longshot works I can only somewhat describe as follows: The Longshot deals enough base damage to actually headshot-kill the meatshield rather than eliminating part of its health which is enough to shatter it (a bit tricky to understand maybe…). This trick will cause a difference of several minutes throughout the entire hive. But I believe the best way to fix this is just to simply fix the meatshield bug altogether (flaw 2).

Flaw 4: Hidden time bonuses
There isn’t many but I currently know of two. One being the active headshot and the other one being the meatshield. They are not represented in the leaderboard where you can see all the time calculated together. Those should be visible somehow in my opinion. Especially the active headshot one. The other one is just a bug by itself already (flaw 2).

Flaw 5: Some enemies not dieing the way you kill them
There is a few enemies that are somewhat weird and do not die the way you think they died and therefore not applying the corresponding time.
Poppers: You may not do a headshot on them. Also a chain-reaction of them blowing up will only have the first one count towards time. They should be fixed.
Bastions: Headshotting Bastions is kinda RNG based. They get the headshot damage and possibly die with it but do not award the headshot bonus sometimes. An Active Headshot makes a difference of 30 seconds, remember that.
Executions via Chainsaw/Bayonet Charge: Those just don’t count as executions but should count as executions in my opinion.

These are mainly the flaws I came up with which should be addressed to balance out the time runs between each individual team and make it more fair. Besides, it is still fun to run for time in my opinion. It at least makes the hives challenging. :wink:

14 Likes
Daily Horde and Escape Challenge Map, Modifiers, and Rewards (Part 1)
Any chance of FIXING the cog tag glitch TC?
Horde Headshot Inconsistencies
#2

Here’s a clue that is mostly reliable for “headshotting” a Bastion :
The “eye” in the middle of it does apply headshot damage(for precision rifles, I’ve never seen a Torque Bow go through there). If you want to count a “headshot” on it you’ll have to land the killshot on top of the corrupted Guardian where you can see an organic Leech-esque mass sticking out. Preferably hit it from the front straight on, seems unreliable otherwise. I don’t know why it’s this way but it is. I found this out by accident when I hit that spot with a Torque Bow and saw I got a headshot kill on the Bastion and recorded a clip to understand how.

As for Poppers, for some reason the game sometimes fails to register the killing blow coming from the player. Seems random when it occurs though.

3 Likes
#3

Good info OP, thanks for sharing it :slight_smile:

#4

Very good point. I noticed applying critical damage on said eye but the Torque actually got stuck on the Bastion and exploded (actually effective…). I’ll definitely give that one a shot.

PS: The Pouncer can als be a tricky one to headshot. Sometimes I can shoot that head in various locations and don’t get crit damage and sometimes I do, no matter where exactly I hit the head. I believe that’s related to its movement. I think the hitboxes change when it’s on a cover piece, trying to shoot you with its stingers.

1 Like
#5

Pouncers in Gears 4 used to be taking headshot damage as you shot them in the head(same used to be possible with Snatchers, where landing a Torque Bow on its head would result in a ton of damage and the arrow passing straight through the beast, and Carrier where a Sniper with Magic Bullet could line up a very precise shot on the chest and head to deal massive damage by going through both weak points).

But in Gears 5, Pouncers and Snatchers will only take increased damage if you hit their belly. And well… it’s a tiny target on a Pouncer. Especially difficult to hit from the front. But it does seem to count as a “headshot” if you hit a kill shot there…

At least for the Pouncer I think that’s what’s going on.

1 Like
#6

I’m not sure if all that aim-assist bullet-magnetism stuff still kicks in but when looking at how inconsistent the headshots are on the Pouncer, I don’t think that my bullet somehow hits the belly. I remember I specifically aimed a bit below the head even and saw the regular body-shot damage applied. Yet I also shot slightly above the head ans saw the critical-hit applied. I still believe that thing just straight up has a strange hitbox.

#7

It might well be, but I just thought I’d mention what I think is going on with the Pouncer. The Campaign would lead you to believe shooting the Pouncer’s belly is the best way to kill one.

#8

Is there a penalty for dying before a saferoom but are resurrected at that saferoom? I know there’s one for dying in the last act and not being able to make it onto the helicopter.

Clayton-ReGeared OP4 (Adv. Horde Tips/Guide) by Hu1k Daddy
#9

I don’t believe so. Only because I ran with a score runner and I died before the first safe and said something like I screwed it up and he said it was no big deal.

#10

It only matters with how many people you escape the hive. People can die inbetween, it doesn’t matter. In case of IronMan, you can just workaround it by rejoining. Although this is rarely of any use since you just lose too much time reviving someone and he also needs to fetch his weapons and possibly get his Ultimate back.

1 Like